Assertion
knowledge is enough
pp. 3041-3056
Abstract
Recent literature features an increased interest in the sufficiency claim involved in the knowledge norm of assertion (KNA-Suff). This paper looks at two prominent objections to KNA-Suff, due to Jessica Brown and Jennifer Lackey, and argues that they miss their target due to value-theoretic inaccuracies. It is argued that (i) the intuitive need for more than knowledge in Brown’s high-stakes contexts does not come from the epistemic norm governing assertion, but from further norms stepping in and raising the bar, and (ii) Lackey’s purported quality-driven case against KNA-Suff boils down to a quantitative objection. If that is the case, Lackey’s argument will be vulnerable to the same objections as Brown’s.
Publication details
Published in:
(2016) Synthese 193 (10).
Pages: 3041-3056
DOI: 10.1007/s11229-015-0914-y
Full citation:
Simion Mona (2016) „Assertion: knowledge is enough“. Synthese 193 (10), 3041–3056.