Acta Structuralica

international journal for structuralist research

Book | Chapter

178987

The mirror stage

a critical reflection

Raymond Tallis

pp. 131-163

Abstract

Over twenty years after the publication of Ecrits,1 the volume in which his major papers are collected, Lacan remains highly influential in certain academic circles on this side of the Channel. Catherine Belse's Critical Practice,2 Terry Eagleton's Literary Theory,3 and The Talking Cure (a collection of essays edited by Colin MacCabe and written mainly by literary critics)4 — to name only a few out of many recent articles and books — testify to the high standing Lacan still enjoys as a clinician and a thinker in academic departments of English Literature in the United Kingdom. In contrast, professionals in the fields in which he operated, or touched on, are in the main ignorant of his oeuvre. Those few who are aware of his writings for the most part consider them to be unnecessarily obscure, self-indulgent to the point of narcissism and even fraudulent. The consensus seems to be that they can be safely ignored. A similar situation prevails in the United States. In 1984, entire issues of Poetics and of Style, were devoted to "psychopoetics', an approach to literary criticism currently almost synonymous with the application of Lacanian psychoanalysis to texts. At the same time, Lacan the clinician and theoretician of the human psyche is neglected by psychologists and psychiatrists.5 His reputation as a philosopher, developmental psychologist and clinician seems to be highest, therefore, amongst those who are trained in the interpretation of literature but who have little or no knowledge of the scientific method and have only a rudimentary appreciation of the nature of clinical practice.

Publication details

Published in:

Tallis Raymond (1995) Not Saussure: a critique of post-saussurean literary theory. Dordrecht, Springer.

Pages: 131-163

DOI: 10.1007/978-1-349-23963-4_6

Full citation:

Tallis Raymond (1995) The mirror stage: a critical reflection, In: Not Saussure, Dordrecht, Springer, 131–163.